Chicago’s Pothole Plague: How the City is Tackling the Pothole Problem Head On

By Sharon Delavega & Brenden Miranda

For decades, Chicago streets have been plagued by potholes located on just about every cross street imaginable.

The issue only gets worse for the city during the winter months, where the city has seen a 20% increase in pothole complaints from the past year, according to city data. And some of them still haven’t been repaired almost a year after reporting, which has the city looking at making changes to its repair process.

According to the American Public Works Association, potholes start to form when water reaches the soil structure of the pavement, causing the pavement to contract. In a summer or winter as brutal as Chicago’s, the thawing of the pavement causes a weakened soil structure, and it’s eventually exacerbated by constant traffic and heavy vehicles.

A pothole located on the corner of Armitage & Drake in Chicago’s Logan Square neighborhood. (Photo/Sharon Delavega)

Angel Medina, a dealer technician at the Berman Subaru dealership in Irving Park, said he’s seen a major increase during the winter time.

“During the winter time, the repairs only increase,” Medina said, and the customers sometimes “miss potholes due to the snow.”

He added that potholes can cause serious damage to vehicles, ranging anywhere from a damaged suspension to disturbing vital steering components. Despite some repairs being covered by insurance, Medina said car owners shouldn’t depend on it, adding that “it can add up and become rather expensive.” Medina mentioned he’s seen repairs go from as little as $250, to exceeding $1,000.

For years, Chicago drivers have reported various complaints to the city’s 311 hotline, including potholes streets or alleyways. Since January 1st, 2018, 29,800 complaints made to the city resulted in 395,000 potholes being patched.

However, since July 1st, 2018, citizens have made more than 64,000 pothole complaints, 9,000 of which still have yet to be resolved. Some of the unresolved complaints date back to July 2, 2018 — this according to an analysis of data on the City of Chicago Data Portal.

This interactive map details open potholes within the Chicago area as of April 9, 2019. Click the photo to explore.

When asked about the open pothole complaints, Michael Claffey, Director of Public Affairs for the Chicago Department of Transportation, said crews “usually fill on the order of 10 potholes for every report that we receive.”

Regarding complaints that have remained unsolved for over 140 days, Claffey explained that there are times where they see duplicate reports, or at times “the pothole cannot be found and officially closed.”

As for the prioritization of what potholes get filled first, Claffey noted that when crews are out, “they look for and fill other potholes that are found along the way.” But he did not specifically address the prioritization topic.

Despite some of the concerns addressed by Claffey, residents of the city still seem to be upset, especially those whose vehicles have been severely damaged as a result.

Alan Valladares, a 22-year-old resident of Chicago’s Brighton Park neighborhood, understands this all too well. When driving in the Archer Heights area this past February, his vehicle suffered damage due to a pothole.

A map indicating potholes located in the city of Chicago, separated by ward.

“I’m usually very attentive when I drive in areas I know have potholes,” Valladares said, “I always try to swerve around them or slow down so that my car doesn’t get damaged.”

Valladares was simply running errands, hadn’t seen a pothole present, and “the next thing I know, I hit the pothole straight on and I was stuck with a flat tire and my rim even got a little damaged.”

When Valladares asked for a professional assessment of the damages, he found himself staring at an estimate of almost $300. Valladares noted that he “didn’t want to pay that much”, leading him to purchase a used tire for $50 and paying his family friend mechanic $100 to help straighten his rim.

When asked if he reported the damage, Valladares said he doesn’t usually report potholes, citing a lack of knowledge around how to report them as a main reason why.

“I was so angry this time that I decided to Google what to do before reporting it,” Valladares added.

The pothole Valladares was referring to was reported to the city on Feb. 15, 2019, having been reported an additional six times, by other people, until it was eventually repaired on Feb. 28. The pothole recently re-appeared on March 11, and was also patched two weeks following complaints.

A large flooded pothole located near N St. Louis & W Cortland in Chicago’s Palmer Square neighborhood. (Photo/Sharon Delavega)

Potholes aren’t just an issue for Chicagoans though, it’s also a problem for other major cities. However, it’s becoming clear that officials within these major cities aren’t quite sure how to surmount the ever-growing number of potholes that appear each year.

A study conducted by the American Automobile Association in 2013 found that potholes were costing U.S. drivers over $3 billion in annual vehicle repairs, yet according to the proposed city budget for 2019, the crew spearheading city pothole repair only amounts to 2.6% of Chicago Department of Transportation’s $543 million budget.

Chicago will be looking into completely overhauling the way they dispatch crews.

In March, outgoing Mayor Rahm Emanuel announced that within the coming months, the city will be patching more than 310 miles of city roadways, including residential streets and alleyways. The department has about 30 crews a day focusing on potholes, and Emanuel spoke of the possibility of adding additional crews.

Claffey said that since 2011, “city forces and utility companies have re-paved a total of 2,165 miles of streets and alleys,” which amounts of almost half of the city’s total 4,600 miles of roadway.

While the city has always encouraged citizens to dial 311 to report any potholes, it also maintains the CHI311 app for iOS and Android, where residents can make service requests and track their progress. It’s a tool that the city hopes it can drive more awareness to.

An interactive graphic aimed to inform individuals how to report potholes within the city of Chicago. (Graphic/Sharon Delavega, Brenden Miranda)

Valladares was pleased to hear about the reporting tool, especially with all of the issues a major city faces, with how quick they were able to patch the pothole. His main gripe was rooted in the fact that the city isn’t driving much attention towards ways for citizens to help out with those sort of issues.

“Now,” Valladares said. “I’m just hoping I don’t hit one on my way home.”

Author: sharondelavega

This website is for Mike Reilley's journalism class.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s